Working Papers

Academic Match and the Returns to For-Profit and Public Colleges [Job Market Paper]

Presented at SOLE ‘26, APPAM ‘26

Short vocational college programs can deliver substantial returns. Public subsidies for these programs are concentrated in community colleges (CCs). Yet CCs graduate only 30% of their students, while two-year for-profit alternatives graduate twice that share. Using administrative records covering nearly all two-year for-profit and public college students in Texas, I use distance instruments to identify college sector effects among students on the for-profit/public margin. For-profits raise long-run completion rates by 32 percentage points, with effects largest among the weakest students. Despite for-profits' higher graduation rates, a within-individual design shows that their degrees yield long-run returns comparable to those of CCs. Expected returns at enrollment exhibit substantial match effects: academically weak students gain more from for-profits because of elevated dropout risk at CCs, while the strongest students earn higher returns from CCs, partly due to the option value of academic and four-year pathways. To better understand mechanisms, I assemble new program-level data on course requirements. For-profit programs require significantly less academic coursework, helping rationalize their comparative advantage for academically weaker students. Finally, I estimate the welfare effects of extending subsidies to for-profits. Accounting for fiscal savings on substitution out of CCs and increased tax revenues, I find the subsidy expansion is self-financing and generates substantial earnings gains.

Can Public Colleges Cater to For-Profit Students?

Presented at APPAM ‘24, SOLE Joint World Conference ‘25, AEFP ‘26

Abstract

Many students choose expensive for-profit colleges for vocational training even though affordable public options are widely available. Such choices are often attributed to information frictions, but this view presumes public options provide close substitutes for for-profit programs. I test this premise using a revealed-preference analysis of students’ choices after abrupt for-profit chain closures. About 30–50 percent of displaced students substitute to public colleges, but those who do often shift to part-time enrollment, slowing their degree progression. Diversion to the public sector is larger where for-profit and public colleges specialize in similar programs. New public programs introduced under a large community-college grant program erode for-profit enrollment only in overlapping fields of study, reinforcing the evidence that limited substitution stems from for-profits’ distinctive vocational programs.

Where Does the Tide Roll? The Causes and Consequences of Out-of-State Enrollment at Public Universities

with Crossan Cooper  |  Presented at AEFP ‘26  |  Media: AL.com  |  Under review

Abstract

Public flagship universities increasingly use nonresident tuition revenues to offset declining state funding. Nationally, we find that public flagships facing lower state support enroll relatively more high-income nonresidents. We then link two decades of University of Alabama (UA) commencement records to admissions office recruiting visits and individual employment histories. These data allow us to document how universities pursue this revenue margin and to measure downstream effects on graduates and state budgets. We show UA boosts high-income out-of-state demand through targeted recruitment visits: in a differences-in-differences design, new visits generate 8–10 percent more future UA graduates. We then trace how nonresident enrollment redirects graduates across state labor markets. Using variation in the state-of-origin composition of UA cohorts and a shift-share instrument constructed from origin states’ non-UA out-of-state enrollment rates, we estimate that every 100 out-of-state students cause 9–15 additional in-state students to leave the state after college. These patterns are consistent with peer effects operating through expanded consideration sets and referral networks. The resulting fiscal losses to Alabama exceed the university’s nonresident tuition margins. Finally, the out-of-state expansion appears to support in-state degree production. A budget accounting exercise shows that UA’s out-of-state enrollment margins are sufficient to cross-subsidize more than half of the in-state cohort, who receive an average annual subsidy of $13,000 per student.

Quality Regulation Creates and Reallocates Trade

with Lucas Zavala, Ana Fernandes, Tristan Reed, & Jose-Daniel Reyes  |  Revise and resubmit at The Economic Journal

Abstract

Quality regulations imposing minimum product standards govern more trade than tariffs. Using disaggregated panel data and a control function to address endogeneity, we show that two main forms -- sanitary and phytosanitary measures (SPS) like pesticide limits, and technical barriers to trade (TBT) like labeling requirements -- increase trade on average, consistent with improved information. However, their distributional effects differ. TBT measures reallocate trade toward lower-income countries, which gain more from information provision. SPS measures favor higher-income countries and cause exporter exit in lower-income countries, which face steeper compliance costs. The burden of quality regulation falls primarily on exporters from lower-income countries.

Work in Progress

Returns to For-Profit Graduate Education

with Joseph Altonji & Zhengren Zhu

Curriculum Design and College Completion: Evidence from Admission Waitlists

College Accountability under Student Selection

Policy Reports

Employment Effects of Unemployment Insurance Generosity During the Pandemic

July 2020, with Joseph Altonji, Zara Contractor, Lucas Finamor, Ilse Lindenlaub, Costas Meghir, Cormac O’Dea, Dana Scott, Liana Wang, and Ebonya Washington

Abstract

The CARES Act expanded unemployment insurance (UI) benefits by providing a $600 weekly payment in addition to state unemployment benefits. Most workers thus became eligible to receive unemployment benefits that exceed their weekly wages. It has been hypothesized that such high benefits encourage employers to lay off workers and discourage workers from returning to work. In this note, we test whether changes in UI benefit generosity are associated with decreased employment, both at the onset of the benefits expansion and as businesses look to reopen. We use weekly data from Homebase, a private firm that provides scheduling and time clock software to small businesses, which allows us to exploit high-frequency changes in state and federal policies to understand how firms and workers respond to policy changes in real time. Additionally, we benchmark our results from the Homebase data to employment outcomes in the Current Population Survey (CPS). We find that the workers who experienced larger increases in UI generosity did not experience larger declines in employment when the benefits expansion went into effect. Additionally, we find that workers facing larger expansions in UI benefits have returned to their previous jobs over time at similar rates as others. We find no evidence that more generous benefits disincentivized work either at the onset of the expansion or as firms looked to return to business over time. In future research, it will be important to assess whether the same results hold when states move to reopen, and to analyze the effects of high UI replacement rates on reallocation of labor both within and across firms.

The Effects of the Coronavirus on Hours of Work in Small Businesses

July 2020, with Joseph Altonji, Zara Contractor, Lucas Finamor, Ilse Lindenlaub, Costas Meghir, Cormac O’Dea, Dana Scott, Liana Wang, and Ebonya Washington